← News
Published on IFSA
Full Federal Court Dismisses ASIC Appeal Against Former Freedom Insurance Director
The Full Federal Court found Freedom Insurance’s sales incentives were conflicted remuneration but upheld the dismissal of ASIC’s case against former director Keith Cohen.
Australia’s Full Federal Court has dismissed the Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s (ASIC) appeal against a ruling in favour of former Freedom Insurance director Keith Cohen, while finding that the company’s sales incentives amounted to conflicted remuneration under the Corporations Act 2001. The court’s decision clarifies the law governing conflicted remuneration, but the finding about the incentives did not change the outcome of ASIC’s proceedings against Cohen: the dismissal of the case was upheld.
ASIC had alleged that Cohen and former Freedom Insurance consultant Robert Oayda were knowingly involved in breaches of conflicted remuneration laws, and that Cohen had breached his directors’ duties. The Federal Court dismissed ASIC’s claims against both men on 16 October 2025. ASIC appealed on 11 November, and the Full Court heard the appeal on 26 and 27 August 2026. ASIC’s appeal concerning Oayda had been withdrawn by consent on 19 December 2025.
The civil penalty proceedings began in October 2021 and concerned sales incentive programs operated by the Freedom Group between November 2017 and October 2018. Freedom Insurance was also a case study during the sixth round of the Financial Services Royal Commission; ASIC said its investigation began before the commission issued its final recommendations. The Freedom Group companies entered external administration in February 2020 and were later deregistered.
Original source: 26-282MR Full Federal Court dismisses ASIC appeal against former Freedom Insurance director
Source published: